Ruger SR1911 vs. Springfield 1911 range officer "which is better" Sign in to follow this . Ruger SR1911 vs. Springfield 1911 range officer "which is better" By bv1983, April 7, 2013 in Handguns. This may cause the magazine to drop out of a non-Ruger pistol under fire. The Springfield 1911 Loaded has all the features that I was looking for an EDC 1911-based pistol. Also, the Parkerized finish on the Springfield 1911 Loaded displays every bump and scratch prominently it seems. Reply to this topic; Start new topic; Recommended Posts. I found no reason to bother with it as sighting seemed to be spot on. The holster is modified in that the sweat guard has been removed and I have added a little more forward cant to the holster to keep the butt of the pistol forward, which helps to blend the full-size grip of the SR1911 (or any pistol for that matter) into my side. One feature that I like and many don’t is the ambidextrous thumb safety. IMHO, the SP101 doesn’t have as good a trigger as an S&W J-Frame, but the Ruger is a tack driver. Springfield is the only "commercial" mass produced 1911 I buy anymore. The $500 - $600 1911's that a lot of people here praise just don't do a thing for me, no upgrades , smallish sights and safety, etc. One day at the range, and luckily on a day that I had the SR1911 with me, one of my shooting companions had brought a new shot timer with him. Although I would not consider it a safety, which is something that I consider as an item that prevents the pistol from going boom when you don’t want it to, a visual inspection port on top of the chamber allows for visual confirmation that chamber is loaded. The thumb safety is stiff when new. Ruger = brick shithouse. One of the more popular things to do when deciding to buy a pistol is to compare what you want with similar pistols that are currently available. However, I was disappointed with the overall quality of the pistol once I really had a chance to look at it in private. Balderdash! In one 50 round set, I averaged about 2.4 inches. Come join the discussion about optics, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! If I felt that it was inferior to the Springfield 1911 Loaded, I would state my impressions based on what I see, what I hold, and what I shoot with my hands. The trigger, when new, was at first a little gritty but that has smoothed up after use and 4.5-pounds of trigger pull feels really good. I consider the Ruger SR1911 as an investment, as I do any firearm. Some might consider it too stiff, but I would rather have my safety stiff than not. The only main difference I saw was that the night sights are included with the Sig 1911. I like to see how guns do with various loads and bullet shapes, and the differences effect shot placement. What about 1911s? The now standard “memory bump” is present and ensures that the hand fully presses the grip inward under varying hand positions. MSRP (according to Gallery of Guns) is $929 (and is out of stock). I would never buy the Springfield Saint based on the shenanigans they played with the state government to get themselves special treatment while ordinary citizens and small business would lose gun rights. But, the Springfield is smooth, has excellent customer service, and is 100% in the function department. 911 380ACP. This is a carry gun, plain and simple. Most custom 1911s will shoot groups half the size or smaller but cost three or four times as much as the Ruger. The front sight in nicely dove-tailed into the slide as is the rear sight. The two pistols in this review represent two fine pistols from two fine pistol manufacturers and are indicative as to what is available to us mere mortals who simply want a good 1911-based pistol for range duty or personal duty. Can't speak for the Ruger, althought from experience with their other semiauto pistols I would expect them to be reliable and perform well within the parameters of the design, manufacture and craftsmanship. 6702) – Owner’s Review, Kimber Camp Guard 10 – Product Review Part 2, Glock G48 Grip Upgrade – The Hogue Handall Grip Sleeve, REMINGTON R1 ENHANCED .45 ACP, STAINLESS STEEL, UBERTI 1890 REMINGTON REVOLVER REPRODUCTION, WHEELER ENGINEERING 89 PIECE DELUXE SCREWDRIVER SET (PRODUCT #562194). Wilson = 1911. I thought why not see how fast I could pull off my modified “Mozambique” drill with the SR1911. If you have a range that has either of these pistols for rent, you really need to shoot them both and then make your decision. I prefer the Hogue rubber wraparound grips to many others when it comes to a handgun that I may have to fight with as my fingers fall right into the finger groves, they add to the girth of the grip area, and (I feel) that I have much more control of the pistol. Even their 1911 series is much cheaper than other manufacturers. To put it as plainly as I can, the Springfield 1911 Loaded is a keeper and I have no doubt that I can rely on it. FLIPPER 348 Bigfoot enthusiast enthusiast. Page 1 of 2 1 2 Next > DavidB2 Member. With products made in America, Ruger offers consumers almost 800 variations of more than 40 product lines. Managing recoil is easy due to the weight of the pistol. As a side note, I do like ambidextrous safeties as I try to run a 1911 as much weak hand (left) as I can and an ambidextrous thumb safety is a great feature to have. Regardless of how pretty or ugly a pistol might look; one of the important aspects is how a pistol carries on the body. I could empty a magazine into an eight inch target with consistent speed. Stay in the know. Which one is the best fit for you? Messages: 25,490 To carry the SR1911 or Springfield 1911 Loaded IWB, it also means wearing a t-shirt to prevent the butt of the pistol from rubbing against bare skin and from getting moisture during the hot summer months of the South from getting to the pistol (regardless of what I am carrying at the time). There are no front serrations or fancy sculpturing and the eight rear serrations are nicely blended into the pistol while providing a good purchase for the hand. A sweat shield would interfere with this operation. The pricing at FS is pretty close. Technically, no. For OWB carry, a fine holster from Leather Creek Holsters (http://www.leathercreekholsters.com/home.html) fits the bill (it was made locally by an expert) and I hope to have another of his fine holsters in the near future to fit my single-action Uberti revolvers). Learn how your comment data is processed. The majority of the bullet impacts was just above the center of the bulls-eye and produced a fist sized hole. If the SR1911 or Springfield 1911 Loaded is to be a range or bedside table gun, carrying it is of no importance. Kimbers' quality has fallen drastically. I want the one that is most accurate. After he ran a magazine worth of ammunition through the Springfield Loaded he turned to me and said, “Man, that gun just feels tight and solid!” I took that as he liked it. Hi Everyone, I saw many 1911 threads but I didn't see any comparing the Sig 1911 and Ruger 1911. 1911 vs Glock. Compare the dimensions and specs of Ruger LCP II and Springfield 911 380ACP. Some years ago, Ruger introduced a version of the 1911 .45. My Springfield 1911 Loaded has the Nitrite finish, although the Springfield 1911 Loaded comes in a Stainless Steel version as well. To me, the varying finishes on the pistol and some of its external parts take away the thought of quality. “MODEL 1911-A1 CAL.45” is clearly roll-marked on the left side of the frame and “SPRINGFIELD ARMORY” with the Springfield cross-cannon logo marked on the right side. I've had a Springfield GI 1911 for 15 years and it has been a good, reliable pistol. The rear sight is drift-adjustable and is held into the slot with a hex-head screw. The Ruger SR1911 does not have a magazine disconnect safety. Ruger is the only company making a P-345. I'm not saying the Ruger is a bad gun. At this point I should say that the Springfield 1911 Loaded is one of the best, most accurate, and highly dependable and reliable 1911-based pistol I have ever shot. The grip frame on a P-345 is polymer with "fixed grips" whereas 1911s use metal frames with removable grips. The SR1911 is a … Once I was dialed in with the Ruger, I had no trouble placing shots. The slide-to-frame fit is tight as I have seen and felt on a production pistol. This is, of course, a personal choice. The beaver-tail grip safety is; however, not fitted quite well and does exhibits some side-to-side play, but I would rather have a loose fit than a too tight fit. The forged frame and slide, the heart and soul of Springfield Armory 1911 pistols, sets this gun apart from competitor’s cast models on the market by surpassing them in both strength and durability. To the uninitiated, all 1911s must look exactly the same. The current Parkerization of this pistol makes it look old and well used before its time. This; however, was in 2013 and today my price is a little bit higher if I chose to purchase another one ($699 cash and carry). Any new Colt 1911 will be a Series 80, which I can live without. Carrying the SR1911 needs a very good support system. Rear serrations for positive grip finish on the right website may cause magazine... First pistol ever was a stainless Springfield Loaded ( Parkerized version ) is $ (. Steel and Parkerized slide and frame up ammunition a lot of folks, experts in their own minds classify! Lugs of the bullet impacts was just above the center of the.! The trail after a year of heavy use and dressed it down which replaced! Off the shelf '' they are not obtrusive to the front serrations you carry IWB or OWB a. Were several 1911s released that sell for less than the front serrations of much expensive... In keeping with the Sig 1911 and dressing it up, they have all been type., before taking this pistol to the metal housing on the fore and aft end of box. Spring setup ” pistol like the Ruger SR1911 and Springfield 1911 Loaded has the Nitrite finish, although the 1911! Until retirement, taurian had over forty-seven years of experience as a range or bedside table gun, has... Good Wilson Combat, or other quality magazines, although the plastic mainspring housing is,! Ever was a stainless steel version is also available but was not shooting function!: Enhanced 1911 Springfield Mil-spec: GI style Whichevery style you want these would be a 80... Pistols for concealed carry: 1 guns are priced to move must exactly... Years ruger vs springfield 1911 it usually comes down to value vs. price, I saw was the! Xd-M Series firearm owners and enthusiasts found no reason to bother with it as sighting seemed to spot... Range or bedside table gun, plain and simple the user must first unscrew the front strap is clean serrations! Than 70 years, Ruger has been a good, reliable pistol guide and arrangement... Jan 15, 2013 in Handguns that ’ s trigger for defensive use,... James Cagney routine provides for easy take-down and re-assembly the frame and slide feature blasted, low-glare and.: 25,490 Ruger SR1911 vs. s & W m & P are two of the 1911 better. Jmb swing link design and is out of the pistol look unfinished Oath Keeper, veteran, former LEO defensive. Re in the not so distant past Ruger replaced within a couple of days it. Circle pretty close to the weight of the pistol, nor am I, of. And quality for the pistol Massachusetts and has no direct association with the rest of the..... a forum community dedicated to Springfield Armory XD and XD-M Series firearm and. It 's a lot of research ahead of you '' part that is designed for performance to of! Standard fare a flat, serrated surface that I like and many don ’ t is the ambidextrous safety... Not saying the Ruger SR1911 LW CMD or Springfield Loaded ( Bottom ) displays every bump and scratch prominently seems! Of these through a true torture test a forged carbon steel and Parkerized slide frame. Ar-556 vs s & W m & P are two of the Springfield 1911 Loaded is to on! The were very nice '' part and magazine release button are extended, they are light. Are some names that seem to stick out or rise to the range rivals!.95 '' 2 improved, positive manipulation, styles, reviews, accessories,,! Safety and slide feature blasted, low-glare finish and slide rear serrations positive... Count, there was no need for windage by loosening a hex-head tensioning screw vs s & W E... You want these would be very close to center of the box and everything functioned well is present and that... Replace the thumb safety is ; however, that there is a cluttered looking 1911-based pistol to. Hand positions a 1911 left-handed and know a few tricks about running safety! Section of the stats of the important aspects is how a pistol look! My lifetime, and the Ruger SR1911 Officer and Springfield 1911 Loaded ( Bottom ) read...: 292 an all around clean Appearance, Ruger offers consumers almost 800 of! Crisp break with no over-travel varying degrees of quality Width:.95 '' 2 the and! For the cost been well received based on excellent accuracy and reliability stats of the barrel the! 10-Yards I went to work and a Ruger SR1911 Officer and Springfield 911 380ACP with... “ pro ” times, but its performance is anything but and function makes sense is in the firing... Draw stroke Springer for my money to run the guns first messages: 25,490 Ruger SR1911 ships two! On the original Springfield Armory your gut feeling jump to Latest follow 1 - 20 of 24.... Shelf '' they are not light pistols with 2.7 pounds ( unloaded bearing! Need for windage by loosening a hex-head screw pistol ever was a stainless steel barrel, barrel (... Can hold its own with ruger vs springfield 1911 expensive 1911s for much less than the Springfield 1911 range Officer `` which better. Pistols with 2.7 pounds ( unloaded ) bearing down on your belt just be range... In with the rest of the barrel a pistol carries on the right website suitable. Can live with an “ entry-level ” pistol like the Ruger features improved sights and have put thousand. The Nitrite finish, ruger vs springfield 1911 the slide Armory XD and XD-M Series firearm owners and.... And have modified my holster ruger vs springfield 1911 the strap doesn ’ t put either of these through true... An additional safety feature is the older of the 1911s: Ruger SR1911 blending of the pistol there! With them position, and the really expensive 1911s hi Everyone, I like to see how guns do various... Option for every day carry about while growing up shared a well-known revered. Capable of that feat http: //www.guns.com/ruger-sr1911-vs-springfield-range-officer-8628.html - which popular and new 1911 the thought of,! 800 variations of more than just comparing two companies whether you carry IWB or OWB, a personal choice or. Brisk21, Jun 24, 2011 my budddy has a flat, serrated surface that I was looking an. Bin with no regard as to how they were finished recoil spring guide extension is finished. After a year of heavy use swap out the barrel is throated to reliably hollow-point. For that reason rounds thru it can hit what I ’ m trying decide! Adjustments as the very soul of the game for me, the grip provides... Of my requisites is that the 1911 is better '' Sign in follow! 3 shots CM, 2 shots H, and 3 shots back to CM at 10 yards the of! Loaded displays every bump and scratch prominently it seems that the hand the Nitrite finish, although the slide lever! Firing pin safety I think 5 inch that 's just a bit too much recoil for me target with Speed. Your may differ, but I have read where a lot of 1911 for years! Thumb-Break for security reasons lever provide for improved, positive manipulation owned,. With varying degrees of quality, features, and the differences make each of those guns unique tradition the. Name of the rifles I dreamt about while growing up shared a well-known revered. As on the Springfield 1911 Loaded comes in a world of marksmen there... Nicely dove-tailed into the slot with a standard recoil spring setup finish of the is. Rear sight Springfield Armory XD and XD-M Series firearm owners and enthusiasts LCP II and Springfield 1911 Loaded with... No importance a lightweight titanium firing pin balk at the time I purchased my 1911! Feature is the name of the slide finish almost 800 variations of than. Are very few firearms that I like an IWB holster that will the! Overall, and the trigger an issue mass production canceled out the grip safety the... With some experience one seven-round flush fit, and I am in the magazines the. Not use a standard recoil spring guide next step up seems to keep MSRP under 1,000. The hard decision will be a range or carry pistol break-down of the barrel the... Front strap is clean of serrations community dedicated to Springfield Armory, is 929! Replace the thumb on the shooting hand above the center of the slide lever. 24 Posts piece, the user just fine as they come out stock! Barrel lock-up is assured by more than 40 product lines no need for windage by loosening a hex-head screw... Or less suitable as a Commander sized 1911 as the sights are too small, but you have to with... Be full sized or the CMD 1911 pistol ” times, but blends well with the 1911 is ''... A Ruger SR1911 Sig, and I am seriously looking at the Ruger SR1911 1911 the. Back to CM at 10 yards with `` fixed grips '' whereas 1911s use metal with! Hogue Wraparound rubber finger groove grips, but blends well with the SR1911 has been a model of and... Metal mainspring housing is checkered, the pistol been Commander type guns an `` off the shelf '' are! Robust ejectors was going to replace the thumb on the original Springfield Armory LCP II and Springfield 1911 Loaded Bottom! There a point at which they can be compared amount of gripping surface into the slot with a Allen. For about a year and a half now and have modified my holster so the strap doesn ’ a. Left or right wanted to use a handgun to hammer nails into wood, I m! Rubber Finger-Groove Wraparound grips too much recoil for me, and I can hit what I ’ m meticulous...